Finding Irish relatives: Part Three

[Editor’s note: This series began with Part 1 and Part 2.]

Until recently, unless you were lucky enough to know the names of your immigrant Irish ancestors’ parents and/or the place(s) where they were born or resided in the Emerald Isle, such information was often difficult if not impossible to find in American records. That imposing brick wall remained unassailable for many seeking to pursue their ancestral connections in Ireland … until now. During 2015-2016 digitized troves of the two most significant sources for Irish family history – Catholic church registers and civil vital records – were released online, freely accessible on any internet-enabled device. Like the notorious Berlin Wall, that longstanding, insurmountable impediment to discovering Irish ancestry crumbled almost overnight.

In 2015 the National Library of Ireland (NLI) launched online its unique and comprehensive Catholic Parish Registers collection: 550 digitized microfilm reels containing more than 3,500 baptism, marriage, and some death/burial registers from 1,086 parishes in Ireland and Northern Ireland (https://registers.nli.ie/). Some registers dated from the mid-1700s but most started a century later, and the released records ended about 1880. However, there were major limitations on using them: there were no accompanying indexes, the registers of each parish could only be browsed one by one, and the 1880 cut-off date was early compared to the availability of church records from many other countries into the twentieth century. The latter situation was particularly regrettable given the large exodus of the Irish, continuing for decades thereafter, which made reliance exclusively on civil records necessary beyond that year. Fortunately, within a year or two Ancestry and Findmypast created indexes to this collection, with links to the digitized records on the NLI site.

Then in 2016 Ireland’s government Department of Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media released the first digitized collection of civil registration records of births, marriages, civil partnerships, and deaths (https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/en/). Currently available are births from 1864 to 1920, marriages 1845-1945 (non-Catholic registrations began in 1845, Catholic in 1864), and deaths from 1871 to 1970. (The years 1864-1870 will be included in a future release, and they are already indexed.) Indexes to these civil vital records had been online earlier, but now one could search the indexes to retrieve results linked to the corresponding digitized records.

The years 1864-1870 will be included in a future release, and they are already indexed.

These new indexed online collections of church and civil vital records made it possible for researchers to overcome longstanding barriers in their quest to discover the ancestral places their Irish forebears lived, and to build their family trees with relative ease. However, as revealed in Part 1 and Part 2 of this series, depending on when particular Irish immigrants lived and how much information is available about them, different research strategies may be required to track them back home. And until the NLI puts a notice on the Catholic Parish Registers main search page about the availability of indexes on multiple external genealogy sites, that wonderful resource will not be fully utilized.

Having learned the hard way that there are multiple paths and pitfalls on the way to discovering Irish roots, I offer the following step-by-step approach to maximize your chance of success. Other search options might well be available, e.g., U.S. death records and Catholic parish records might reveal the names of deceased immigrants’ parents and/or their abodes in Ireland, but for most researchers the methods laid out below will probably yield that critical information much faster.

Before we begin, a few clarifying points are appropriate. First, for ancestors born to Catholic parents before extant baptism records, the steps that involve parish registers are obviously irrelevant; however, if you find them using other sources you may be able to find additional information about them and/or their families in surviving marriage, death/burial, and/or congregational records of the relevant parishes. Second, for non-Catholic ancestors, look for and search church records of the relevant denominations. In the late nineteenth century, 80-90% of the Irish population was Catholic, so the methods recommended below should work in most cases.

Third, aside from the civil registration records, I have limited recommendations to the “big four” genealogy megasites (Ancestry, Findmypast, FamilySearch, and MyHeritage) for a host of practical reasons: they are familiar to family historians, they have bountiful resources, two of them have indexed the NLI Catholic Parish Registers that are essential sources, they are widely accessible for free, and they will likely produce success quickly. Finally, and most importantly, although the recommended research strategy below was conceived from the perspective of an American descendant of Irish immigrants, these steps will work for those researching Irish roots whether or not their ancestors emigrated.

Recommended Research Strategy

  1. Start with Ancestry, especially if you know the name of at least one parent. The site has more than 150 Irish databases and multiple search filter options. It is a paid subscription site, but you can access its so-called Library Edition for free at many public libraries, more than 5,000 Family History Centers (FHC) operated worldwide by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, as well as at some genealogical and historical societies. In any event, consistent with free access to NLI’s Catholic Parish Registers collection, Ancestry allows free searches of those now-indexed records. You can use the global search function, limiting results by relevant filters, or you can use the “card catalog” to find and search “Ireland, Catholic Parish Registers, 1655-1915” with images from the NLI collection.

Regardless of which database(s) reveal(s) your ancestor’s place(s) of birth/residence, continue searching Ancestry to fill in family lines backward and forward.

For individuals who were born, married, and/or died in Ireland after 1864, regardless of religious affiliation, search the civil registration records covering the years available for each category as noted above. This will supplement and cross-check the parish records up to about 1880, and thereafter serve as the only comprehensive source of vital records into the twentieth century.

  1. Next, search Findmypast, which has 248 Irish record sets including five separate Irish Catholic Parish Registers (baptisms, marriages, burials, and miscellaneous congregational records for some parishes; and a browse option) with links to the NLI images. Like Ancestry, it is a subscription site, but its indexed collections of parish registers and associated NLI images are free, and its Library Edition is also free at FHCs and some public libraries and other research facilities. Its search functions are not as flexible as Ancestry’s, but its extensive holdings of unique records make it an essential resource that should be exploited fully.
  2. By now, having exhausted the resources on Ancestry and Findmypast, you will most likely have found your Irish ancestors and be well on your way to fleshing out multiple new family lines and learning a great deal about their lives and times. If you were not successful, go to Step 4. If you had success in Steps 1 and 2, the third step is to explore relevant records on FamilySearch and MyHeritage. All the resources on FamilySearch are free, and its databases include all kinds of useful records covering just about every place on the planet, including hundreds on Ireland. MyHeritage has more than 100 Irish databases; it is a subscription site, but its Library Edition, like those of Ancestry and Findmypast, is free at FHCs and other subscribing institutions.
  3. For non-Catholics, anyone born after ca. 1880, and anyone else who was not found in the indexed NLI Catholic parish registers, search the civil registration records as follows:

For individuals born before 1864:

  • if the names of both parents are known, search civil death records from 1864 for each parent, and use a process of elimination and triangulation to co-locate their deaths in the same town or townland; as related in Part 1, this technique worked for me.
  • if found, search the surname(s) of interest in the civil births, marriages, and deaths in that locality since 1864, to find additional family members and other useful information.
  • search Ancestry, Findmypast, FamilySearch, and MyHeritage to discover more about your newly-discovered ancestral relations.

For individuals born in 1864 and after:

  • if the names of both parents are known, search birth records for the person of interest to find one whose parents match.
  • if sufficient information is available to narrow the identity of an individual (e.g., approximate birth date, name of one parent, county or other local jurisdiction where the person was born or lived), search the civil birth records.
  • if there are too many candidates, limit searches to registration districts/offices in the vicinity of the individual’s known or probable residence (there are many online maps and guides to Ireland’s administrative divisions); and/or, after 1898, filter searches by mother’s maiden name (this information was not recorded previously).
  • if found, search the surname(s) of interest in the civil births, marriages, and deaths in the registration districts/offices where they lived since 1864, to find additional family members and other useful information.
  • as above, search Ancestry, Findmypast, FamilySearch, and MyHeritage to discover more about your newly-discovered ancestral relations.

Happy hunting!

About Joe Smaldone

Joe Smaldone and his wife Judy Warwick Smaldone have been researching their family’s history for 20 years. Their research has taken them to many national, state, and local libraries, archives, court houses, churches, cemeteries, historical and genealogical societies, and other research sites across the United States, and abroad to Ireland, Italy, and Sweden. They are members of NEHGS, the New Hampshire Historical Society, and the New York Genealogical and Biographical Society. Joe is an adjunct professor at Georgetown University, where he created and taught a course entitled Your Family in History. He is a Genealogy Research Consultant at the Family History Center, Annapolis, Maryland, and has published several genealogical studies, abstracts, and indexes.

6 thoughts on “Finding Irish relatives: Part Three

  1. searching for Irish couple who were in Goderich, Huron, Ontario, Canada by 1833.
    They were NOT Catholic.

  2. So many of the Irish who left for US and Canada did so well before 1864. Also there are the Church of Ireland records that were before the Catholic Church was recognized in Ireland.

  3. Thank you for all three of these posts, Joe! I have, so far, searched in vain for records of my great-great-grandmother, Margaret Elizabeth Ryan. We know no parents’ names and only that she came from “County Cork”, though that may be only the port she left from in about 1835. This gives me a bit more hope, and, just as important, a strategy.

    1. A second Thank You to John, especially for this step-by-step outline. Printing out all for tucking one copy into the Marie Daily book on Irish research. Like Lucinda, I have a “from County Cork” person too, though 40 years later, my father’s grandmother — a Molloy! But a brother came too, so I have at least two names to triangulate.

  4. Great post Joe – thanks for your thorough efforts in getting us familiar with source material and what can be done.

Leave a Reply to Robert M Gerrity Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.