This past June, I was excited to attend the first workshop ever offered by NEHGS in Seattle. It was a bit of a drive from my home in Salem, Oregon, but definitely worth it, and the most useful thing I learned was that many older Massachusetts deeds can be browsed free of charge through FamilySearch.org.
I’d hoped one day to revisit the Massachusetts island of Nantucket – where a branch of my family lived for the first two centuries of European settlement – largely to do additional investigation at their Registry of Deeds. The staff there was incredibly helpful when I visited in 2013, but even in the off-season, staying on the island is not exactly cheap, especially with a cross-country flight thrown in. Imagine my joy to discover that I could now do this work from home 24/7!
Speaking of Nantucket, there is a strong connection between that island and the city of Seattle … but it’s not what you may be thinking. People often assume that the Starbuck family, early purchasers and colonizers of Nantucket, founded the coffee company bearing their name, but (sadly for my bank account) this is not true. According to its most pervasive creation myth, the global coffeehouse chain was named for Starbuck, first mate in Herman Melville’s novel Moby Dick.
So what is the connection between Nantucket and Seattle, and why might I care? Back when my grandfather was born in 1906 – shortly after his mother survived the San Francisco earthquake – he was given the name Folger, another old Nantucket name long associated with coffee.
In due course, my father was named Folger Athearn, Jr., and then my brother was given Folger as a middle name. (Naturally I loved to reveal this to his friends, with predictable teasing ensuing.) The only thing my brother and I knew about his torturous name was that it was in honor of some man on the East Coast who had tracked down my great-grandfather in California to bestow a legacy.
Early in my genealogical work, I discovered that Folgers Coffee was founded during the California Gold Rush by a Nantucket native named James Athearn Folger, and that his oldest son went by the name of Athearn Folger. Surely there had to be a connection! As it turned out, however, “our” Mr. Folger’s origins lay in another direction. Thanks to a copy my aunt had of the letter accompanying our ancestor’s legacy, I discovered that Mr. Folger was G. Howland Folger of Boston … the only surviving son of George H. Folger, a native of Nantucket and nephew of my great-great-great-grandmother, Lydia Ramsdell (Starbuck) Athearn.
I then happened upon the blog of Andrew Craig Magnuson, describing the schooner Exact, which brought the first white settlers to Seattle. The Exact was owned at the time of this 1851 trip by George H. Folger; his uncle Obed Starbuck (dubbed Nantucket’s “Golden Boy” by historian Nathaniel Philbrick); Henry Coffin, his uncle by marriage; Edward H. Morton, a distant cousin of mine through other branches of my tangled Nantucket family tree; and Captain Isaiah Folger, son of renowned island genius and Congressman Walter Folger.
A few years before its historic voyage, the ship had been owned by my great-great-great-great-grandfather, Levi Starbuck; his grandson, George H. Folger; and his son-in-law, Henry Coffin. I was beyond thrilled to discover that my family’s ship had played a pivotal role in the founding of Seattle! I was also intrigued that all its owners were either named Starbuck, or had close relations by that name … so there really is a Seattle connection to the Starbuck family, but it has nothing to do with coffee.
As for that Folgers Coffee guy, a red herring, it turns out that he was named for my great-great-great-great-grandfather, James Athearn, a merchant and ship owner, as well as cashier (and later president) of Nantucket’s Pacific Bank.
Before driving home from NEHGS’s Seattle seminar, I visited two monuments commemorating the schooner Exact. One is a granite obelisk on the beach where the ship landed; the other is a Duwamish story pole carved by a descendant of Chief Si’ahl, for whom the city was named. I had only a vague idea where they were located, but eventually I tracked them both down. After all, if my family could navigate uncharted seas, I could surely find two memorials on a small peninsula!
 James Athearn Folger (1835–1889) was succeeded in the family business by a son and grandson bearing his name. Another descendant by the same name was born in 1982.
 My father’s only sister married a man whose brother is named Peter Folger Herb. It seems that our family is keeping the famously endogamous “Nantucket stew” on a low simmer!
 George Howland Folger, Jr. (1857–1924) worked for many years for the Boston & Maine Railroad, finishing his career as assistant general superintendent.
 George Howland Folger (1816–1892) represented Nantucket in Massachusetts’s General Court in the early 1850s, then moved to Boston and later Cambridge.
 Lydia Ramsdell (Starbuck) Athearn (1813–1889) and her sister Eliza (Starbuck) Coffin (1811–1903) considered and referred to themselves as sisters of George H. Folger, since he was reared in the home of his maternal grandparents following his mother’s death, and they were only a few years older.
 Henry Coffin also owned (with his brother) the whaling ship Achushnet, which Herman Melville sailed on; Melville’s experiences on this ship inspired his novels Typee and Moby Dick.
 James A. Folger was a first cousin of George H. Folger; they appear in the uppermost left section of an illustrated Folger family tree owned by NEHGS, and available as a reprint through their online store. Capt. Isaiah Folger’s branch of the family had split off several generations previously.
 James Athearn (1784–1852) was born in Providence, Rhode Island. In 1806, he moved to Nantucket, where he soon married his first cousin, Lydia Cary; he died in Boston.
16 thoughts on “A Starbuck in Seattle”
Dear Pamela: This kind of research is what keeps any of is going and thoroughly enjoyed reading yours. The West Coast on my paternal line (mainly in NE Wasington) means so much to me. So I know what you are saying finding all about your Ancestry there. Well Done, well maybe should not say done, there is always more. Thank You for sharing:)
There are some Coffins tangled up in my tree, too, but I am NOT going there! I need to wear blinders in order to finish any thought I have. And I would like to have STAFF so that I can go off on some other excursion while my STAFF is doing the original research.
Hello cousin! I am descended from Thomas Macy, with Chase, Gardner, Folger, and a host of others from Nantucket. I guess we’re just two peas in that “Nantucket stew”. ;o)
I am a descendant of Edward Starbuck; Nathaniel Starbuck and Mary Coffin Starbuck line. All of this is so exciting. I love researching and finding family history treasures!
I believe that’s a rock from Plymouth, Mass. imbedded in the monument.
The tree you shared is incredible! A thing of beauty & a joy to behold – as the old saying goes. How is that created? Is there a program to accomplish this or what marvelous system do you use? I want one.
As much as I would like to think you’re referring to the boxes and lines I created to illustrate the family of Levi Starbuck and Elizabeth Ramsdell (a descendant of John Ramsdell/Ravensdale, featured in the latest issue of the NEHGR, by the way), I feel sure that you’re referring to the exquisite Folger family tree. I have never seen the original, but I feel sure that it was lovingly created by hand in the mid-19th century.
Yes, you are correct. According to the plaque beneath it, the piece of Plymouth Rock was brought overland from Massachusetts by “the first transcontinental motorized caravan” and unveiled September 4, 1926…so almost exactly 91 years ago.
To my knowledge I have not heard or seen the Athearn surname before I read your entry in Vita Brevis earlier today.
A few hours after reading your post, I was browsing through the Cambridge Chronicle, (Volume I, Number 12, 23 July 1846) in search of an elusive great-great-great-great grandmother’s death notice and there it was again! From an article about the great Nantucket fire:
“Among those who have lost the heaviest amounts of property are Aaron Mitchell, H. Mitchell, Geo. Myriek and James Athearn.”
I often find serendipitous little connections in my own research and thought it was neat to see your ancestor’s name twice in one day.
Yes, serendipity abounds in genealogy. While I was writing this blog post, my husband and I happened to visit the house where we lived as newly-weds. The 1892 house was recently sold, and excavations around the foundation exposed two small bottles, one of which was embossed with “J A Folger & Co San Francisco.” What a coincidence! I look forward to sharing more about James Athearn in the future, the guy I like to call “Nantucket’s Biggest Loser.” He suffered the greatest losses in each of Nantucket’s worst fires: 1836, 1838, and 1846.
We have the same roots. My line goes back through Levi Starbuck Athearn. Do you have the whole chart from Thomas?
William James Athearn. (Jim)
Rev. Jim, it’s great to make your acquaintance! Yes, I not only have Tom Athearn’s amazing one-name study, I finally got up the nerve to phone him on the 300th anniversary of Simon Athearn’s death two years ago. We all are in Tom’s debt for doing such an amazing job decades ago in seeking to track down every Athearn in the country and fit them into the matrix. Our branch of the Athearn family through Levi Starbuck’s brother Frederic William is very tiny…and only my brother and his son carry on the Athearn name. Since finding an unknown genetic match in our line would have been a BIG SURPRISE, I was very excited to get a match recently to one of your second cousins, descended from Carl Rhea Athearn. It was like finding a needle in a haystack, and such fun!
I too have Starbuck, Coffin, Macy, Folger, Gardner, Prickett, Pike, Peacock in my tree. Hello to all my cousins.
Your name was familiar to me, and when I read your bio at the end of your article, I realized it was because you had accompanied one of your SSHS students to a DAR meeting of the chapter in which I am a member.
I was honored to be with him and his mom this past spring. Your members seemed very excited, too, that this year’s Chemeketa Chapter winner was also the area and state essay contest winner. Mateo is a great kid and will be starting college later this month. He was admitted to Cornell, but chose to attend Oregon State Honors College instead. Go Beavs!!
Thank you for the feedback on Mateo.