Richard Mitchell & Co.

The grave of Richard Mitchell Sr. in Nantucket’s Prospect Hill Cemetery, draped with his company’s house flag.

One of the many benefits of pursuing genealogy is the chance to meet long-lost family members. In addition to the possibility of finding old photographs, documents, and family stories through them, the acquaintance itself can be a blessing. This past month, Oregon became the final state in “the lower forty-eight” that my fifth cousin once removed visited, and I was excited to host him and his wife for a couple of days.

My husband and I first met Cousin Dick last September when he led a tower climb at Washington National Cathedral. Once the climb was over, Dick pointed out a few details in the cathedral connected to our shared family legacy on Nantucket, and I was able to give him a Richard Mitchell & Co. flag, which I’d recreated from old paintings. You see, Dick is the sixth man in a row[1] to be named Richard Mitchell, so it only seemed right that he should be able to fly the old “house flag.” In days of yore, each whaling ship flew a flag identifying the house (company) it belonged to, as well as a unique flag identifying the ship by name.

Massachusetts to California

It’s probably not surprising that Dick’s genealogist great-aunt identified him decades ago

The graves of Susan Lincoln (Mitchell) Folger, alongside those of three of her children (Susan Starbuck Folger, George Howland Folger, and Richard Mitchell Folger) and a nephew/step-son (Philip Howland Folger). The pointed gravestones in the near distance are of patriarch Paul Mitchell, Richard Mitchell Sr., and other Mitchell family members. The bevel-faced rectangular stones to the left of the pointed stones mark the graves of Richard Mitchell Jr. and his wife Charlotte (Morton) Mitchell.

as the future keeper of their family’s history; after all, his name embodies it! Following the 1846 Great Fire on Nantucket, Richard Mitchell (1791–1868) built a brick spermaceti candle factory, which now comprises part of the Nantucket Historical Association’s Whaling Museum. Within a couple of years, gold was discovered in California, and the next Richard Mitchell (1817–1888) headed out West, as did an enormous number of other men from Nantucket.

Richard Mitchell Jr. left Boston on 9 December 1848, aboard the bark John W. Coffin. It is not unlikely that he was part of the crew, since he later became a sea captain. The master of this voyage, however, was his brother-in-law Charles Cary Morton; another brother-in-law, Andrew Jackson Morton, made the journey to San Francisco with them.

They arrived 28 July 1849, and obviously met up with my great-great-great-grandfather at some point. When James F. Athearn tried to sell the ship Japan, an ad in the 5 March 1850 issue of the Daily Alta California directed would-be purchasers: “Apply to James Athearn, or A. J. Morton and R. Mitchell, jr.”

No doubt they also crossed paths with another of Richard Mitchell’s brothers-in-law, Edward Hussey Morton. Edward made his way to California as captain of the schooner Exact, and retained part ownership when it took the first white settlers to Seattle in 1851.

Folgers, Mitchells, and Athearns

Another owner of the Exact was George Howland Folger, also an intimate member of

The gravestone of George H. Folger and his second wife, Mary Ann (Mitchell) Folger, at Cambridge Cemetery. The graves of three of their children are visible in the background. Mary Ann’s unmarried sister Amelia, who lived with them, is buried here as well.

Richard Mitchell’s family. George H. Folger had married Richard Jr.’s older sister—Susan Lincoln Mitchell—in 1838, and together they had four children. Sadly, Susan died in 1844 shortly after the birth of twin sons.[2] The following year, George married his late wife’s younger sister, Mary Ann Mitchell, and they had six children together.

George H. and Mary Ann (Mitchell) Folger were also close family to my great-great-great-grandparents . . . quite literally, since they appear adjacent to James F. and Lydia (Starbuck) Athearn in the 1850 federal and 1855 Massachusetts censuses. More details about George—including my family’s debt of gratitude to him—were shared in a previous post: vitabrevis.americanancestors.org/2017/11/have-family-around-him/.

George H. Folger ties us to a terrible tragedy

The timing of Cousin Dick’s visit to Oregon is a bit ironic, and here’s why: George H. Folger ties us to a terrible tragedy that unfolded fifty years ago this month. While George stayed in Massachusetts, three of his Folger first cousins caught Gold Fever and headed to California; the youngest was named James Athearn Folger.[3] He made his fortune, not in gold, but in coffee. Abigail Folger, James’s great-granddaughter, was staying at a friend’s house on 8 August 1969, when followers of Charles Manson killed everyone in it. Sadly, Abigail was in the wrong place at the wrong time . . . the victim of an evil “family.”

Notes

[1] Dick’s great-great-great-grandfather was not even the first in the family to be named Richard Mitchell; Richard Mitchell (1791–1868) was a son of Paul Mitchell . . . who was a son, grandson, great-grandson, and great-great-grandson of men named Richard Mitchell.

[2] One of the twins was named Richard Mitchell Folger, after his maternal grandfather (and uncle).

[3] Believe it or not, this guy was not closely related to me, but was instead named for my ancestor.

About Pamela Athearn Filbert

Pamela Athearn Filbert was born in Berkeley, California, but considers herself a “native Oregonian born in exile,” since her maternal great-great-grandparents arrived via the Oregon Trail, and she herself moved to Oregon well before her second birthday. She met her husband (an actual native Oregonian whose parents lived two blocks from hers in Berkeley) in London, England. She holds a B.A. from the University of Oregon, and has worked as a newsletter and book editor in New York City and Salem, Oregon; she was most recently the college and career program coordinator at her local high school.

4 thoughts on “Richard Mitchell & Co.

  1. What an amazing family link you have to California history. I am glad you got the genealogy bug and are delving into connections and relationships. Your knowledge is invaluable to coming generations.
    By the way, I remember the Manson murders. The newspaper in my northern California town initially headlined, “Folger heiress murdered …”, later it seemed the focus was on actress Sharon Tate. It was a horribly gruesome crime.
    And a third thought, was Richard Mitchell descended from Matthew Mitchel(l), one of the founders of Stamford, Connecticut, in 1640?

    1. This line descends from the immigrant Richard Mitchell (supposedly born around 1686 in Brixton on the Isle of Wight to a man named Richard), who died in Newport, Rhode Island in 1722. His son, also Richard, moved to Nantucket prior to the birth of HIS son Richard. That Richard had no (known) son called Richard…otherwise cousin Dick would be Richard Mitchell 11th at least!

    2. No. Per Hinchman’s EARLY SETTLERS OF NANTUCKET, the first Mitchell in our line arrived in Newport, Rhode Island, in 1708.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.