Remembering Robert Gould Shaw (all of them)

The Shaw Memorial overlooking Boston Common.

Robert Gould “Bob” Shaw, a longtime staff member at NEHGS, passed away last month at the age of 82. Bob had worked in several positions at NEHGS, including associate editor of our magazine NEXUS, assistant editor of our magazines New England Ancestors and American Ancestors, and for many years as archives assistant in the R. Stanton Avery Special Collections. Bob was also interested in his own genealogy; an amusing anecdote arose when a member asked what Shaw family he descended from, and Bob replied “the right one.”

Bob was one of several men of the same name in his family, although only the first one, Robert Gould Shaw (1776-1853), was in his direct ancestry. This first Robert Gould Shaw was born in Gouldsboro, Maine, a newly-settled town created from land given to Robert Gould, Col. Nathan Jones, and Francis Shaw in 1764 by the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (which then included Maine). Francis Shaw and Robert Gould were both merchants from Boston, and the latter was the namesake for both the new town and the eldest son of Francis Shaw, Gould’s business partner. Francis Shaw had worked hard to develop Gouldsboro, and reportedly died broke because of it, and his son Robert Gould Shaw returned to his parents’ native Boston.

The most well-known of the name was Col. Robert Gould Shaw (1837-1863) of the Massachusetts 54th Regiment, the first regiment of African American soldiers in the Civil War, semi-fictionalized in the movie Glory. Colonel Shaw was killed in 1863 at the Second Battle of Fort Wagner in South Carolina and was buried with his fellow soldiers. A bronze memorial to Shaw and the 54th Regiment can be found on Boston Common, near the Massachusetts State House; it was recently restored and rededicated. Colonel Shaw himself was the third of that name after his grandfather and uncle. Bob wrote a review in the 2000 Register of Where Death and Glory Meet: Colonel Robert Gould Shaw and the 54th Massachusetts Infantry, on the history of his namesake first cousin three times removed.[1]

[When] a member asked what Shaw family he descended from, … Bob replied “the right one.”

The simplified chart I prepared below outlines all the men to date with the name Robert Gould Shaw. This chart does not identify all male Shaw descendants, only those with the shared name or those that are ancestral to men with that name. Using retroactive suffixes, Bob Shaw of NEHGS was the ninth of his name and was in the sixth generation, one year older than the tenth Robert Gould Shaw who was in the fifth generation. If any readers find an additional Robert Gould Shaw that I missed, I will happily update the chart with the appropriate suffixes.

As Bob’s obituary notes, he was also a longtime member of the Society of the Cincinnati, a fraternal hereditary society founded by officers of the Continental Army and Navy at the close of the Revolutionary War. Bob represented his great-great-great-great-great-uncle, Capt. Samuel Shaw (1754-1794), Aide-de-Camp to Major General Henry Knox. Captain Shaw joined the Society at its formation in Fishkill, New York, in 1783, serving as Secretary of the Officers who organized the new organization. The Society allowed for hereditary membership to the next male heir. As Captain Shaw had no children, membership passed to his younger brother William Shaw (1756-1803), and afterwards to their nephew, the first Robert Gould Shaw; he was in turn succeeded by his son Francis George Shaw, the father of Colonel Shaw, who would have succeeded to membership had he not died in the Civil War. As Colonel Shaw had four sisters, membership then passed to his first cousin George Russell Shaw (Bob’s great-grandfather), where membership was continued for four successive generations, and Bob was the senior male heir of the Shaw family.[2]

Click on image to expand it.

Note for Chart: Robert Gould Shaw “V” (1872-1930) married twice. His son on the chart, Robert Gould Shaw “VII”, was by his first wife Nancy Witcher Langhorne (who after her divorce married Waldorf Astor, 2nd Viscount Astor). By his second wife, Mary Hannington, Robert “V” had a son Gould Shaw (1904-1955), who is mistakenly identified as “R. Gould Shaw” in the 1920 census.

Notes

[1] The book also notes that as a child Colonel Shaw met many prominent anti-slavery people, including William Lloyd Garrison, Harriet Beecher Stowe, and Lydia Maria Child, this last included in my recent post on Child cooks.

[2] James Archer O’Reilly III, Memorials of the Massachusetts Society of the Cincinnati (2004), 344-46. As Bob’s younger brother was adopted, through “agnatic primogeniture” the next senior male heir of the Shaw family is Bob’s third cousin once removed (not on the chart) – Samuel Parkman Shaw “VI”, sharing the same name as his father and grandfather, the last a son of Samuel Parkman Shaw “III” (1877-1973) on the chart. If considering “male-preference primogeniture,” the most senior male heir of the Shaw family is a great-great-grandson of Colonel Shaw’s sister Anne (Shaw) Curtis. Col. Shaw’s younger sister Josephine Shaw married General Charles Russell Lowell, and is treated on page 38 in The Descendants of Judge John Lowell of Newburyport, Massachusetts.

About Christopher C. Child

Chris Child has worked for various departments at NEHGS since 1997 and became a full-time employee in July 2003. He has been a member of NEHGS since the age of eleven. He has written several articles in American Ancestors, The New England Historical and Genealogical Register, and The Mayflower Descendant. He is the co-editor of The Ancestry of Catherine Middleton (NEHGS, 2011), co-author of The Descendants of Judge John Lowell of Newburyport, Massachusetts (Newbury Street Press, 2011) and Ancestors and Descendants of George Rufus and Alice Nelson Pratt (Newbury Street Press, 2013), and author of The Nelson Family of Rowley, Massachusetts (Newbury Street Press, 2014). Chris holds a B.A. in history from Drew University in Madison, New Jersey.

10 thoughts on “Remembering Robert Gould Shaw (all of them)

  1. Thank you, Chris. I mention Robert Gould Shaw IV every time I do a tour of Katharine Gibbs School in the Back Bay. RGS IV designed 151 Commonwealth as a first home for his new bride Isabell Pratt Hunnewell. He also designed the contiguous 303 Dartmouth for his brother-in-law Arthur Hunnewell. Another brother-in-law lived across the alley at 315 Dartmouth. There was a family compound here before Mrs. Gibbs created her first Boston campus in the 1920s (303 Dartmouth, 151 and 135 Commonwealth). Your post is very clear and will make my July tour better. I will give you credit.

    1. Rose, my great-grandparents bought 315 Dartmouth Street from the estate of T. Jefferson Coolidge — my great-aunt was married from there in 1928, and my grandfather at one time owned the building as trustee of a family trust. My grandmother grew up around the corner at 127 Commonwealth Avenue.

      1. Scott, your family would have seen Gibbs students playing badminton and quoits next to the alley. Gibbs was at this campus from 1925 to 1953, when the school moved closer to the Public Garden. Your grandmother may have been aware of Gibbs students.

        1. I’m sure she was aware — perhaps she joined in. Neither one of my grandmothers went to college, although my maternal grandmother trained as an artist in Europe. Just a generation later, my mother went to college … in fact, she was so old a bride (24!) that the Baltimore paper called her a “post-debutante” — autre temps, etc.

          1. Tours are better when I can do more than answer questions by quoting from backbayhouses.org. People really enjoy knowing things like the inhabitants of 315 “might” have seen Gibbs girls (as they were called) playing behind 303 Dartmouth and 151 Commonwealth. autre temps

          2. I have some photos of my family at the house — one is of my great-grandmother, great-aunt, and great-aunt’s daughter, all named Theodora, in front of 315 Dartmouth Street ca. 1931.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.