Top 10 published resources continued

In an earlier Vita Brevis post, I introduced a free webinar that I conducted in August on the Top 10 Published Resources for Early New England Research. The Vita Brevis post was the first in a series of upcoming posts that will break down the top 10 list into individual discussions. The first post addressed what makes a published resource a “top 10” and analyzed the first published resource on the list, the Genealogist’s Handbook for New England Research. Today I will continue the conversation and talk about the second and third, in the “no particular order” list, of top 10 resources: Mayflower Families through Five Generations and New England Marriages Prior to 1700.

Mayflower Families through Five Generationsalso known as the “Silver Books,” is published by the General Society of Mayflower Descendants (GSMD).

The Silver Book project was conceived in the late 1950s with the goal of documenting the first five generations of the Mayflower passengers who left American descendants. It is interesting to know that of the 108 passengers and crew on the Mayflower, only fifty are known to have descendants; of those fifty, only twenty-five left American descendants. After the GSMD decided to pursue this huge project, it took nearly twenty-five years for the first volume to be released in 1975. Each volume in the thirty-one-volume series includes sketches of those American descendants.

The work in these books is based on findings presented in carefully researched articles from respected genealogical journals, verified family histories supported by probate and land records, town and church vital records, and other primary sources. The sketches are written in Register format with the first generation given the number 1, and each of the children identified with a Roman numeral associated with the child’s birth order. Each child who will later be listed as a parent in the next generation is given an Arabic numeral, allowing efficiency when searching for descendants.

The Register style offers a beginning, middle, and end format for communicating genealogical research. The beginning introduces the Mayflower passenger by providing verified vital information. The middle is usually a biography in chronological order, and the end lists children and their vital data. When enough information is available, the children are continued in their own sketch as part of the next generation.

As research continues beyond the first five generations of Mayflower descendants, the new research is called Mayflower Families in Progress, or the “Pink Books.” They are available in paperback and, once completed, the Pink Books will become Silver Books. Currently the Pink Books cover George Soule, Richard Church, and William Brewster, and Philip Delano, who sailed on the Fortune in 1621.

Initially the Silver Books had been accessible only in print format, but AmericanAncestors.org and the General Society of Mayflower Descendants partnered to digitize and index the fifth generation, making it available to members of both organizations.

The Silver Books are an essential resource for anyone wishing to prove their Mayflower line and a top 10 resource for early New England research.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New England Marriages Prior to 1700 by Clarence Almon Torrey. This series is also known as Torrey.

Mr. Torrey scoured every book, manuscript, and periodical available to him at NEHGS between 1927 and 1960, resulting in the enumeration more than 99% of the known or presumed marriages in New England before 1700. He collected the marriages by writing them down on a slip of paper, along with the sources for the information collected, and then alphabetized the slips by groom’s surname. The slips were then rewritten onto whole sheets of paper bound into 500-page volumes covering 37,000 marriages.

This published work is considered a finding aid, which is a tool that helps a user access information. It can be thought of as something like a table of contents or an index: the finding aid assists in locating a specific record, collection, or piece of archival material.

It is important to note that Torrey’s was not created to be a proven vital record – it was created to be a finding aid to the published records that support the marriageThere can be inconsistencies and mistakes, but the text has remained in the original format and these errors and omissions are addressed in the footnotes or in bracketed interpolations.

It can be thought of as something like a table of contents or an index: the finding aid assists in locating a specific record, collection, or piece of archival material.

There are various editions of Torrey’s work. The most recent came out in 2011, and includes a list of sources and a comprehensive every-name index, making this an efficient and effective finding aid.

Despite the title suggesting this is exclusively a New England resource, there are a few other geographic areas included. Because much of Long Island, except for the westernmost part, was settled by New Englanders, Torrey included couples who settled or were married in Suffolk, Nassau, and Queens Counties. He also included couples who left Greenwich, Connecticut for parts of Westchester County, or migrated from New England to settle in Newark, Elizabeth, Piscataway, Woodbridge, or Cape May, New Jersey.

Torrey’s list is alphabetized by the groom’s surname and first name. Those with unknown first names are placed at the end of that surname section. The births and deaths are placed in parentheses and are available for both the groom and the bride. When a ? Is included, it represents a probable date. When there is a “+,” it indicates the person was living in that year and died at an unknown later date. The bride’s name is given in full when it is known, and in that case, it is usually seen with an actual marriage record. When the bride’s surname is within brackets, it is based on a good deal of confidence based on indirect evidence, such as a will or a deed. When the bride’s name is preceded or followed by a question mark, Torrey was less certain of the bride’s identity. When a bride’s name is given as two underscores, Torrey has found evidence of a wife but nothing about her identity is known. When a full marriage date is given, the record itself is almost always in existence, but if the date includes a “b” it indicates they were married “by” that date. Other abbreviations used are “abt” meaning about, and “ca” meaning circa.

The sources in the sketches are a cryptic shorthand of Torrey’s own creation, so examining the source list key found in volume III is essential to getting the most out of this resource. The source list includes all identified sources, but some remain unidentified. Most of his sources were located at NEHGS and can be found in the stacks, at the reference desk, in the manuscript collection, on microfilm, or in databases at AmericanAncestors.org.​

New England Marriages Prior to 1700 has been completely digitized and indexed at Americanancestors.org.

Tricia Mitchell

About Tricia Mitchell

Tricia Healy Mitchell is a genealogist at the New England Historic Genealogical Society and a graduate of the Boston University Certificate program in Genealogical Research. Her areas of experience and research interests include New York, Maine, Massachusetts, and Ireland. She authored the Portable Genealogist: Probate Records and she is a member of the team offering lectures and webinars at the American Ancestors Research Center and at AmericanAncestors.org. She holds a Bachelor of Science degree in business from the University of Maine.

6 thoughts on “Top 10 published resources continued

  1. Trisha – Great information!! – I saw this and have a question: “… the General Society of Mayflower Descendants partnered to digitize and index the fifth generation, making it available to members of both organizations.” Can you tell me is there a link for the GSMD members to access the Silver Books?

    1. Thank you for the great question Jeff. There is not a direct link from the GSMD website to the Mayflower 5th generation database. Don LeClair, Associate Director, Database Search & Systems, and Kathleen Mackenzie, Manager of Member Services informed me that all member of American Ancestors are able to access the database from AmericanAncestors.org. GSMD members can get 10% off membership renewals, or 30% off new memberships with us. The codes for those offers are either GSMDNEW or GSMDRENEW.

  2. I was not aware that only twenty-five passengers left American descendants. Would you be kind enough to identify those passengers. Also, how do you define American ? Does that included the descendants that went to the Canadian Provence’s ?
    I am curious as I descend from 16 proven passengers whose descendants went to Nova Scotia before or shortly after the Revolutionary War.

    1. We have a wonderful and interactive website that identifies all of the passengers and specifies those with American descendants. You can find the website at https://mayflower.americanancestors.org/passenger .
      If a Mayflower passenger had children in America, and descendants of those children went to a Canadian province, then yes the Canadian descendants would be included in the Silver Books. Thank you for the great questions.

  3. I have heard that there is work under way to extend the work to the sixth or even seventh generation of descendants. Can you confirm or refute (I have a proven fourth great grandmother whom I believe is the daughter of a known Mayflower descendant, but I have yet to prove her parentage)?
    Many thanks and looking forward to more listings – the webinar was excellent!

    1. Research on the Mayflower passengers with American descendants continues beyond the 5th generation and is published under the title Mayflower Families in Progress. This project is also known as the “Pink Books” and once completed, the Pink Books will become Silver Book. The Pink Books can be found in the American Ancestors Research Center on the 7th floor, and for purchase through various online sources.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.