I first stumbled upon the disturbing history of Malaga Island while conducting research on the descendants of enslaved individuals. Located in Casco Bay, Maine, Malaga is a 42-acre uninhabited island now listed on the National Register of Historic Places, but it was once home to a mixed-race community of about forty to fifty fishermen, laborers, and their families, initially settled in the 1860s by the descendants of Benjamin Darling.1 These families were evicted in 1912 by the state of Maine after being vilified as “paupers” and “degenerates”—notions fueled by an anxious tourism industry, eugenics, racism, and classism. In Part I of this series, I gave a short history of Malaga Island and its residents’ tragic expulsion. If you haven’t read it, you can catch up here.
Often, a deeper understanding of place and historical context aids genealogical research; for Malaga Island, it was essential. Conventional records, like births, marriages, deaths, and even census entries, were spotty or nonexistent. And names common to islanders—Darling, Marks, Griffin, Tripp, Eason—were often interchangeable. It was a puzzle that poverty, discrimination, and the resulting off-the-grid living can present. Ultimately, tracing people who have reason to avoid the authorities—whether descendants of enslaved people in the 1800s or Germans fleeing the Palatinate in the 1700s—is challenging genealogical research.
To supplement traditional vital records, I looked to the state apparatus intending to document, and ultimately evict, the families on the island. Because Maine considered many Malaga residents “paupers,” the “Pauper accounts” of George C. Pease, agent for the Malaga group of islands, became my most useful record source. They list the heads of families receiving assistance between 1905 and 1907, giving me family groups and important surnames, as census or town records might have.2
There, in the pages of Pease’s “Pauper accounts,” I found evidence of a family on Malaga Island led by John Eason and Rosella Griffin/Marks/Darling.3 John and Rosella married in about 1885. By the 1890s, Phippsburg and Maine were working to evict Malaga’s fishermen and laborers, but John and Rosella’s family—like many of their neighbors—remained firmly rooted there for another twenty years. In 1900, they were enumerated on Malaga Island, a district of Phippsburg, Sagadahoc County, Maine, with a son, Robbie Eason, about sixteen.4 Robbie was John Eason’s step-son, Robert E. Tripp, the son of Rosella Griffin/Marks/Darling and Henry Tripp. He was born shortly before John Eason and Rosella married.5 John and Rosella were still on Malaga in the 1910 Federal Census, which reports they had four children together, one of whom survived.6
By many accounts, conditions on the island were challenging, though for a time largely self-sufficient. Nevertheless, the poverty and racial composition of islanders contributed to significantly negative press about the island and its residents. Criticism focused primarily on the families’ poverty, their lack of education, and the unconventional family structures and high rates of “illegitimacy” recorded there. On 9 April 1906, Pease wrote:
There are a number of children there that ought to attend school, and there are other things also that ought to be attended too, such as men and women living together who are not married, and rearing illegitimate children, selling liquor & short lobsters, and various other things. There ought to be some arrangements made by which we can handle them.7
Indeed, the repeated hand-wringing about “illegitimacy” in these files gave me clues to community naming conventions, helping me trace individuals who kept changing surnames, like John’s wife, Rosella, who used—almost interchangeably—Griffin, Marks, Darling, and Eason. In one note dated 19 July 1907, Pease reports: “There are a number of illegitimate people [on Malaga Island] and some go by their mother’s maiden name and some by the one they suppose to be their father. They are mixed so that it is a conundrum to tell their real names.”8 Thus, Pease’s records of “illegitimacy” aided my genealogical efforts, contextualizing marriage records to help me identify the parents of children.
The critical attention drawn to islanders led to intense state scrutiny and state assistance: a double-edged sword. On 8 January 1906, Pease wrote: “There is quite a lot of suffering on the island this winter. The papers are having quite a lot of criticism about them. Shall I furnish some of them wood and bedding that need it.”8 The following year, on 1 February 1907, Pease wrote to Hon. C. D. Newell: “I would very much like to have you come down and see in what condition the people are on these islands. There are some things over there that need looking after, such as schools & etc. which should be seen to before legislature adjourns.”10 Although such reports helped islanders access basic necessities, they could then be branded as dependent on the state—a problem in need of solving. Whereas the state spent $48 on Malaga residents in 1902, by 1910 it was spending $1,710 and had begun sending children to “the state home in West Pownal.”11 Thus, an imposed dependency “became their undoing.”12
The Malaga Island Memorial lists the names of former residents who are now buried at the Maine School for the Feeble Minded (photo via Paul Van Der Werf, CC 2.0 license).
The state’s solution was a forced eviction in 1912. Practically overnight, residents were expected to vacate the island and take all their belongings. The state exhumed remains from the island cemetery, removing them to the Maine School for the Feeble Minded, including three of John and Rosella’s children.13 A witness to the trauma, a first-hand account from one of the evicted residents, was printed in the Bath Independent on 9 March 1912:
Decon [sic] John Eason has given up preaching and prayer-meeting through the troubles on his mind of leaving his old home and seeing all the old folks go too. And William Griffin and George Marks after a long search found nobody would keep them but everyone wanted them to keep out of their way, so these two natives are going to bunk on Hermit Tripp’s little island up the New Meadow’s River where their minds will be easy….The others of us are having hard times to find homes anywhere; all on account of folks saying we’ve got the cramp-catch in our fingers and take too many things that are lying around loose. But it’s all a lie; we don’t steal if we are poor….Uncle Jim McKenny is taking down his house today and Professor Eason will go next. If you know any place where I can crawl in with my wife and five kids and my old peg-leg please let me know.14
Robert Tripp, Rosella’s eldest son, endured great hardship during and after the eviction:
Robert E. Tripp’s family who, having rafted their house on a hull, sailed up New Meadow’s river in search of a lot but were prevented from landing by ‘prosperous Christian people’ and town authorities. Caught literally between the well-known rock and a hard place, the family hawsered up to some trees on tiny Bush Island. They were barely able to eke out an existence, and often bordered on starvation.15
After the eviction, John and Rosella Eason resettled near their daughter, Hattie (Eason) Newman, in Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine, where they were listed in the 1920, 1930, and 1940 Federal Census.16 Hattie died of a fractured skull on 6 January 1936 after being struck by an automobile on the Bath-Brunswick highway.17 Rosella died at Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine on 25 September 1941.18 John died there on 20 December 1942; his neighbor was the informant on his death record, and no parents were listed.19
The destruction of the community at Malaga Island is painfully represented by John and Rosella’s family. Though difficult to examine, the details of their lives, and the mechanisms that dismantled their self-reliance, survive in seldom-considered state records like the “Pauper accounts.” Though designed to document, sort, and finally dispose of individuals belonging to a “degenerate” community, these records were instrumental in helping me follow family groups through an extremely traumatic transition that split families, destroyed gravesites, and uprooted generations of stability.
Sources
[1] Charles N. Sinnett, Benjamin Darling of Casco Bay, Maine and Descendants, (Fertile Minnesota), accessed on Ancestry.com, p. 15; William David Barry, “The Shameful Story of Malaga Island,” Down East, (Nov 1980), p. 84.
[2] Maine, United States, Pauper Records, 1888-1907, FamilySearch.org, Patten-Phippsburg box 22, film no. 005732044, begins with image 389. LINK
[3] Phippsburg, Maine, Pauper accounts by town, Box 22, 2112-0614, [FSL 005732044], image 389- 423 of 423, for John Eason.
[4] 1900 U.S. Census, Phippsburg, Sagadahoc Co., Maine, ED 0214, roll 599, p. 13, household of John Eason.
[5] Maine, Vital Records, 1892-1907, [FSL 004703979], image 1888 of 3934, for Robert E. Tripp; Cemetery record image at FindaGrave.com, memorial no. 176106057, for Robert Tripp, Cranberry Horn, Great Sebascodegan Island, East Harpswell, Cumberland Co., Maine.
[6] 1910 U.S. Census, Phippsburg, Sagadahoc Co., Maine, ED 0218, roll T624_545, p. 4b, household of John Eastman.
[7] Phippsburg, Maine, Pauper accounts by town, Box 22, 2112-0614, [FSL 005732044], image 389- 423 of 423, for John Eason.
[8] Phippsburg, Maine, Pauper accounts by town, Box 22, 2112-0614, [FSL 005732044], image 389- 423 of 423, for John Eason.
[9] Phippsburg, Maine, Pauper accounts by town, Box 22, 2112-0614, [FSL 005732044], image 389- 423 of 423, for John Eason.
[10] Phippsburg, Maine, Pauper accounts by town, Box 22, 2112-0614, [FSL 005732044], image 389- 423 of 423, for John Eason.
[11] Barry, “The Shameful Story of Malaga Island,” p. 84.
[12] Barry, “The Shameful Story of Malaga Island,” p. 84.
[13] Gravestone image at FindaGrave.com, memorial no. 115875508, for “Three Easton Children,” Pineland Patients Cemetery, New Gloucester, Cumberland Co., Maine.
[14] Barry, “The Shameful Story of Malaga Island,” p. 85.
[15] Barry, “The Shameful Story of Malaga Island,” p. 86.
[16] 1920 U.S. Census, Harpswell, Cumberland Co., Maine, ED 18, roll T625_639, p. 11B, household of John Eason; 1930 U.S. Census, Harpswell, Cumberland Co., Maine, ED 0020, p. 1A, household of John Eason; 1940 U.S. Census, Harpswell, Cumberland Co., Maine, ED 3-31, roll m-t0627-01474, p. 1B, household of John Esson.
[17] “Cummings Exonerated For Auto Tragedy,” The Bath Daily Times, (Bath, Maine), 7 Jan. 1936, p. 5.
[18] Maine, Vital Records 1936-1955, at American Ancestors, for Rosella Eason.
[19] Maine, Vital Records 1936-1955, at American Ancestors, for John Eason.