The story apparently first appeared in print in the 1893 History of the Town of Hampton, New Hampshire by Joseph Dow (p. 783). Dow may have been a descendant of Henry Lamprey through his daughter Elizabeth, who married Daniel Dow. His version reads: “A pretty story (of the truth of which there is little doubt) has been handed down for generation to generation, that this little wife received for her marriage dowry a scale, containing her weight (one hundred twelve pounds) in gold.” Dow claimed that the chest which held the dowry was then (in 1893) in the hands of a descendant in St. Paul, Minnesota.
Pretty story, indeed! It was repeated and expanded in 1931 by Elizabeth Goodhue Fuess in her typescript, “Cushing and Allied Families” (p. 279), and she calculated that the value of the gold came to $25,000! She also added: “Misplaced confidence and bad management had lost nearly all of it before they moved to Hampton and by the burning of their house, they lost everything in the form of fabrics, except what they had on themselves while harvesting.”
Neither of these accounts cites a source beyond “family.” The classic compendium for Maine and New Hampshire families – Genealogical Dictionary of Maine and New Hampshire (p. 409) – makes no mention of the story in its sketch on Henry Lamprey, but in the back of the book there is a section of additions and corrections. Under Henry Lamprey is the note: “The Toppan ms. has the early trad. given by Dow, and more.” Since the “tradition” was not published in the Genealogical Dictionary, this notation is more than cryptic, but coming at it from this angle, I recognized the clue.
Turning to the NEHGS library database on AmericanAncestors.org, I found that our manuscript collection includes a photocopy of a transcription of an original 1845 manuscript by Edmund W. Toppan entitled “Result of researches into the transactions of the first settlers of the town of Hampton…” (Mss 159). Tim Salls at R. Stanton Avery Special Collections kindly scanned the two pages on Henry Lamprey for me.
Toppan, indicating the information was “tradition,” gives a longer version of the story beginning with “There was a poor man in London” who married an heiress who received her weight in gold as a dowry, but she was shunned by the family for marrying a lowly cooper, so they went to the colonies. Lamprey started off well as a merchant in New England, but a captain ran away with his ship and cargo, and Lamprey purchased land at Roxbury Neck that had a bad title, and, well, things went downhill from there.
Toppan does not mention the chest that Dow knew about in 1893, but it is probable that both Toppan and Dow got the story through the descendants who inherited the chest. We still don’t, of course, know who wrote down the story, when, or how likely they were to know the true facts of the case, but someday the original family version may surface. Let me know if you have it!
